7 Actionable Tactics to Increase Subscriber Engagement in 2025

Subscriber engagement measures how actively subscribers participate with your brand emails.

Email marketing provides ROI as high as 4100% for every $1 spent, but only if your subscribers are actually engaged. A little while before, engagement was measured through email open rates. However, with Apple’s new privacy settings, open rates are no longer a reliable engagement metric, pushing email marketers to adopt a new golden standard: Subscriber engagement.

Engagement levels impact email deliverability and the overall brand experience, making it necessary to offer compelling email content to drive action.

While content is one aspect, email segmentation strategy and email personalization tactics play a key role in keeping subscribers eager to receive brand messages.

So, let’s start by understanding the basics and focus on the creative strategies to increase subscriber engagement in 2025.

---

---

What is a Subscriber in Email Marketing?

An email marketing subscriber is a person who has given you permission to send them promotional messages. They often require nurturing through their lifecycle to move through the email marketing funnel until they become paying customers.

The subscriber lifecycle in email marketing is not always linear. Subscribers may move back and forth in the funnel, and some may not progress through all of them. Building an effective subscriber lifecycle strategy is a holistic approach to delivering personalized communication at every touchpoint in the email marketing customer journey.

Although subscribers demonstrate active interest through the marketing journey, keeping the spark alive takes more than sending weekly email marketing newsletters.

But before we discuss email engagement strategies, it’s important to understand what they are and how to use them.

---

What is Email Marketing Engagement?

Email engagement refers to how subscribers interact with your emails, and is a direct measurement of their interest and involvement with your content. 

A high engagement means subscribers enjoy interacting with your emails — they open, click through, and respond to the messages. 

Effective subscriber engagement is crucial for improving email deliverability and maximizing conversions. 

But where do you start and how do you manage subscribers?

We’ll learn the strategies below!

---

The Basics of Subscriber Engagement 

Collecting valid email addresses (Subscribers) is just the starting point; you must nurture relationships, provide value, and ensure your subscribers remain engaged. 

This step-by-step guide will help you manage subscriber engagement effectively.

1. Understanding and Segmenting Your Audience – The Foundation for Engagement

Having a large email list is great, but engagement is what truly matters. A solid email conversion rate happens when you understand your subscribers’ needs.

Use email segmentation strategy to divide your email list based on demographic data, psychographic variables, geographic values, and behavioral traits. 

Segmented email campaigns drive 30% more more opens and 50% more click-throughs than unsegmented ones. 

Analyze the existing customer data — what type of content performs the best? And who are your most engaged subscribers? Use this information to build personalized email campaigns for each target demographic.

If you’re unsure or do not have enough data, don’t be afraid to ask. Run polls or send email surveys to gather feedback. Understanding subscriber preferences is crucial for providing relevant content at their preferred time.

2. Crafting Compelling Content (The Heart of Engagement)

Content is the heart of your email marketing strategy; it holds power to alter subscribers’ decision-making. Use effective email copywriting techniques to persuade subscribers to take the necessary action.

As you tell compelling stories, pay attention to optimizing your email design for enhanced engagement. 

3. Optimizing Email Design and Deliverability (The Mechanics of Engagement)

Email design and deliverability are interlinked — an email that follows email design principles is more likely to improve email deliverability and sender reputation. As you choose an email campaign template, ensure it’s optimized for mobiles. Most people check emails on phones (around 46%), so this is crucial.

4. Encouraging Interaction and Feedback (Building Relationships)

While sending promotions and email coupons may increase engagement, they are usually short-lived. Subscribers will quickly move on to the next email they find intriguing and leave your messages unopened. 

The best way to avoid this scenario is to give them a compelling reason to stay. Use interactive emails, run contests, and use social sharing to improve email engagement. You can also urge customers to forward your emails or reply to the questions you leave in the email sign-offs.

Regularly review consumer data to optimize email campaigns effectively.  

5. Analyzing and Iterating (The Cycle of Improvement)

Monitor open rates, click-through rates, conversions, and unsubscribe rates to analyze the campaign results that worked for your audience. Additionally, experiment with different subject lines, email content, call-to-action buttons, and sending times to optimize email engagement.

The above ideas are the technical aspects of email marketing and form the base for successful subscriber engagement. The best way forward is to combine these tips with creative engagement strategies.

We hope you’re ready for some inspiration from real-life brands.

---

7 Creative Email Engagement Strategies 

If you want to boost your email open rates, click-through rate, and overall engagement, it’s time to move away from the standard newsletters and try creative approaches.

These seven strategies will inject creativity and increase engagement in your email marketing.

S.NO	Strategy	What to do
1.	Email gamification	Add interactive elements like scratch the car, spin the wheel, or quizzes to encourage engagement.
2.	User-generated content	Feature customer testimonials, reviews, and implement word-of-mouth-marketing to instill trust.
3.	Personalized product recommendations	Use AI-driven product recommendations based on purchase history or recent interaction.
4.	Countdown timers	Create urgency for sales, product launches, or event registrations with timers.
5.	Storytelling emails	Include brand narratives, behind-the-scenes content or personal anecdotes to increase curiosity.
6.	Exclusive early access and VIP perks	Start a loyalty rewards program to incentivize regular customers.
7.	Interactive quizzes and polls	Reveal results in a follow up email or include quizzes to excite subscribers.

Tailor each of the above strategies to match the customer journey. For example, nurture subscribers with valuable content in the engagement stage and use the upsell funnel after they convert into customers.

You’ll have a clearer picture of your email performance and subscriber engagement by tracking the email engagement metrics. Always adjust your strategies based on what resonates with your audience.

Now that we understand the basics, it’s time to look at how other brands have implemented these strategies.

1. Email Gamification – Attracting Email Subscribers

Email gamification is the process of engaging your audience playfully. It’s about adding fun and interactivity while boosting engagement. This strategic approach increases the likelihood of subscribers interacting with your emails rather than passively reading them.

So, what can you add to the emails to double the fun? Here are your options.

Gamification Type	What Should the Users Do?	Example
Spin-the-Wheel	Users spin a digital wheel for a chance to win a discount or prize.	“Spin to Win! Unlock up to 50% Off on Your Next Purchase”
Scratch Cards	Subscribers “scratch” (by clicking/tapping) to reveal their prize.	“Scratch & Reveal: A Mystery Discount Awaits”
Quizzes & Challenges	Engage users with personality quizzes, product match tests, or trivia.	“Which Car Suits Your Lifestyle? Take Our Quiz & Get a Special Offer!”
Treasure Hunts	Hide clickable elements or Easter eggs in emails that lead to rewards.	“Find the Hidden Key & Unlock an Exclusive Deal”
Leaderboard & Rewards	Award points for actions (clicks, purchases, referrals) and track them.	“Earn Points & Climb the Leaderboard – Top 5 Get Free Gifts”
Memory or Puzzle Games	Mini-games that require user interaction to solve a challenge.	“Match the Pairs & Get a Surprise Discount”
Countdown & Limited-Time Challenges	Urgency-driven gamification where users must act fast to win.	“Flash Sale: Unlock a Bonus if You Purchase in the Next 15 Minutes”

2. User-generated Content – Instilling Trust in Subscribers

User-generated content (UGC) leverages the real experiences of current customers to attract potential clients. Instead of solely relying on brand messages, it showcases authentic voices, making your emails more relatable and trustworthy.

Sharing UGC emails makes your current customers happy, leading to repeat purchases while encouraging potential clients to try your brand.

3. Personalized Product Recommendations — Increasing Email Marketing Engagement

Using customer and behavioral data to provide tailored product recommendations makes your emails more engaging and conversion-friendly. Sending subscribers whatever they were looking for shows you value their needs and preferences.

A product recommendation email can be a cross sell to the product they purchased before or an abandoned cart email, urging them to complete the purchase.

4. Countdown Timers – An Email Engagement Strategy to Increase Urgency

Countdown timers create urgency, encouraging people to take immediate action before the offers run out. These timers play by the email marketing psychology rules and leverage FOMO (Fear of Missing Out).

The best part is, you can include a timer for any type of email campaign. For example, you can build anticipation leading to a product launch with a countdown timer. Similarly, you can also increase sign-ups and attendance by including an event countdown in your event invitation emails.

Our clients can use a simple third-party countdown timer in the Campaign Refinery dashboard to increase email engagement quickly. 

5. Storytelling Emails — Steering Brand Narratives

Stories in emails help form special bonds with subscribers by creating deep emotional connections. Instead of merely selling a product, stories create an experience, making subscribers a part of the brand journey.

Personal and authentic stories make products and services feel more valuable, turning more subscribers into loyal brand advocates.

6. Exclusive early access and VIP perks – Rewarding Loyal Subscribers

Adding subscribers to your email list is one thing, and retaining them is another. Loyal subscribers need special treatment in the form of exclusive rewards, coupons, and early access to deals.

This makes them feel valued, increases retention, and boosts sales. 

Most subscribers stay engaged for long-term perks. You may also entertain your loyal customer base by including interactive elements in your emails.

7. Interactive Quizzes and Polls — Creating Excitement for Subscribers

Interactivity in emails boosts engagement by making the audience feel involved. They get to participate, pick answers, or rate an element, making the process fun.

The more fun your quizzes are, higher the chances they’ll get forwarded. Plus, when subscribers pick an answer, you have insights into their likes to tailor future email campaigns.

Use these creative tips to boost engagement on top of using robust email marketing strategies we discussed earlier. 

Using them the right way ensures your email deliverability and ROI witness growth. But how is email engagement related to deliverability and ROI? 

We’ll examine them below.

---

Impact of Email Engagement on Deliverability and ROI

Email engagement is not about clicks and opens — it directly affects deliverability and, in turn, your email ROI. Regular email clients like Gmail and Yahoo track how subscribers interact with your emails. 

High engagement signals that your emails are wanted, improving sender reputation and inbox placement. On top of that, emails with high engagement rates bypass spam traps because ISPs (Internet Service Providers) do not suspect these messages to be spam.

Higher deliverability means more of your messages reach the inbox, increasing visibility. Engaged subscribers are more likely to open and interact with your emails, maximizing email marketing ROI.

Key Takeaways of Email Engagement

Better engagement = Higher inbox placement.

More clicks & opens = Higher conversions.

A well-maintained list = Increased ROI.

To achieve all of the above, you’ll need a reliable email marketing tool that can organize your email list, manage subscribers, and engage them the right way.

Let’s introduce you to the all-in-one email marketing tool with the highest email deliverability rate in the industry — Campaign Refinery.

Work With the Best Email Marketing Tool for Increased Subscriber Engagement

A high email deliverability rate automatically increases the likelihood of better subscriber engagement. At Campaign Refinery, we have a strict email sending policy, and we handpick clients to maintain standards.

Our robust authentication, high-speed sending engine, and mandatory email domain authentication for all customers ensure exceptional inbox placement rates.

Elevate subscriber engagement with top-notch segmentation, list management, and email deliverability tools — apply to become a Campaign Refinery client now!

---

FAQ

What is an engaged subscriber?

An engaged subscriber is someone who actively interacts with your email by clicking, forwarding, or replying to.

What is a good engagement rate for a newsletter?

A good engagement rate for newsletters is 20-25% open rates and 2-3% click-through rates.

How do I increase my newsletter subscribers?

How to get 10,000 email subscribers?

The best way to get 10,000 subscribers is to use a mix of organic, paid, and viral marketing strategies.